The Quintessential Apple Pie

A rainy evening in Singapore, I sat curled up on the favorite spot of our studio – the couch by the wall sized window that paints lush green Apple Piegardens, wide skies and high-rise buildings together in a single view! (Apart from the kitchen, this is where I spend most of my time ..well, that is when I am at home! 😉 ) Coming back, it was a rainy evening,  I felt as snug as a bug in a rug lying on my couch , sipping hot coffee and watching a chick flick – “Waitress”. With a rating of  7.1 on IMDb, for all those who are interested, Waitress is a comedy drama about life and dreams of a woman who works at a pie diner.

What appealed me the most about the movie? The frames that captures interesting pies that protagonist Keri Russell bakes in her head depending on her state of mind. She even names them accordingly – “I hate my husband Pie” or “All in love Pie”! It does sound a li’l silly but subtly it did make me realize that more often than not, even the menu in my kitchen decided by my temperament . ( Does that happen you as well?)

Somewhere, somehow, while watching the movie, the image of the primmed and trimmed criss-cross pie got stuck in my head.  I started wondering that I had tasted it so many times at different places before but why didn’t I try it till now? Is it too difficult? Does it require special tools? Are the ingredients too hard to fetch? Can it be made without eggs? The questions were endless but needed to be answered!

Three days of research and googlearning later,  I realized that the ingredients and tools needed for the Apple Pie were as simple as they could be. In-fact almost everything required was available in my kitchen shelves and yes, the flaky pastry crust as required for the pie could be made without using any eggs… Whoa, I was inspired and as ready as ever! What are we waiting for?

So, here’s to my first Pie with the criss cross or lattice top and  I would like to call it ” Pie-Oh-My”!

Here is the list of  Simple Ingredients that I used:Apple Pie

Flour – 2 cups
Butter – 125 gms
Baking powder – 3/4th tsp
Apples – 3 medium (you may choose any kind or can
even mix different varieties of apples)
Spices ( Cinnamon Powder+ Nutmeg Powder) – 1 tsp
Sugar ( preferably brown and ground)-  3/4th of a cup  ( or adjust to taste)
Lemon juice – 1 tsp 
Corn Starch – 1 and 1/2 tsp
Ice Cold Water –  a little over 2 cups
The Process:

Frankly, from the very beginning, I could not wait to start arranging the lattice dough strips on the pie, but clearly, that wouldn’t have been possible till I completed the two main steps – To begin with, knead the pastry dough and then marinate the apples, both of which require some time and patience.

 CRUST of the PIE:

1. Cut 100 gms of butter in small cubes and put it to chill in the freezer for at-least 15 mins soaked in 2 cups ice-cold water.

2. Sift 2 cups of flour and add 2 tbsp ground sugar and 1 tsp baking powder together

3. Now , add hardened butter cubes and start cutting them through the dry flour mixture using forks . The idea is to have grainy butter pieces coated well with the flour mixture,  if it’s too hot in your kitchen and you feel that the butter getting too soft , refrigerate it for sometime and/or move to a aircon cooled room. Do whatever it takes to get a grainy dough. ( It is the coarse butter granules between in the dough that make the Pie Crust flaky!)

4. Once you reach that stage, bind the dough using ice-cold water. Put half tsp at a time. The idea is to use as little water as possible, so that the resultant dough is firm and non-smooth. ( Refer to the picture below) Try not to use too much of hands/pressure in the dough kneading process or the butter would melt due to the body heat through your palms.

“A pie dough comes together exactly like a biscuit only there is very, very little liquid and no leavening involved. Other than that, the same rules apply. My best advice: handle the dough as little as possible. “     -Alton Brown 

5. Cover the dough in cling kitchen wrap and put it to refrigerate in the freezer for about 20-25 mins ( ensuring any softened butter gets firm before the rolling process).

Pie Dough


1. Peel and de-seed the apples and cut them into thin and small bite sizes.

2. Sprinkle the cinnamon and nutmeg powder, remaining sugar and 1 tsp of lemon juice. Toss Gently and let them sit for over 15 mins.

3. Transfer the apples into a sieve resting over an empty bowl for about 30-45 mins. The bowl will collect the juice from the softened apples.

4. Mix the corn starch over the collected juice and thicken it in the microwave for about 15 secs, mix it back to the apples.

5. The  softened apple filling is ready to be poured into the pastry crust.

Apple _Marinate

 ROLL out:

The crust might get a little hard when you remove it from the refrigerator but as you start lightly kneading it, it would get easy to manage. The dough should ideally be firm and elastic ; you have to use it before the butter gets too soft and  consequently  makes the dough sticky. 

1. Divide the dough into two parts and by the time you are rolling one, keep the other back in the fridge

2. Take a clean flat surface and lightly flour it. Roll out the dough into circle of a size bigger than your pie baking mould,  this measurement makes pie of size 8″ diameter.

3. Care should be taken that the pie crust doesn’t stick/break, if it is becoming unmanageable then you can roll out the dough by placing it in between sheets of cling wraps, by doing so it can be easily transferred to the baking dish.

4.  Lightly grease the baking dish with butter and dust some flour.

5. Roll  the flattened pie on the rolling-pin and roll it out on the baking dish; Firmly press it while sticking the pastry dough neatly to the sides of the bakeware

6. Roll out the other remaining  dough from the fridge and cut it into thin stripes – approx width of 3/4 th inches

Apple Pie Hungerlane


Finally comes the most interesting and creative part of the whole process, the pie top arrangement. You can make pie open-faced, with a full top, or half-open like a lattice top. We used the lattice top crust as it not only looks pretty but also  provides heat insulation to the fruit and does not let them become too caramelized. For big pies , the double crust ( top and bottom) works better as it gives every piece a perfect wedge shape and the filling remains neatly sealed in.

Steps to weave your Lattice Pie:

1.   Being excited and impetuous, I took the shortest way started by arranging the strips parallely at a small distance from each other in one direction. ( Needless to say, the longest strip should cut through the center and ends of all the strips should reach till the edge of the pie crust)

2.  Next, I started arranging another set of strips, perpendicular to the previous arrangement starting from one end. The only difference was this time I put one strip  at a time and I alternately put it over and under the existing arrangement, creating a criss cross weave.

 3.  Cut the excess strip ends hanging from the sides after leaving some margin. Now tuck the strip ends neatly into the edge of the bottom crust.

4. You can now create a crimping effect on the edges by using your thumb and index fingers. If you are using a crimped pie plate, you will have to just press the edges firmly on to the crimped circumference.

Just like that you are done!

Tip! If the process above  took sometime and you feel the butter of the crust might have got softened.  Refrigerate the pie  for 10 mins before baking.



1. Brush the crust with a little butter and/or milk mixture to get a brown glaze. Put it into preheated oven at 250 degrees C for over 1 hour.

2. Since I have an oven with double rod options, I let the base cook on the bottom rod for over 30 mins before putting on the top ( and consequently both) rod on. This ensures that the pie doesn’t over brown. ( If you do not have that option, you may choose to put an aluminium foil around the edge of the pie to keep it from turning too brown and remove it towards the last 15 mins. )

3.  The apple filling bubbles up and the liquid might ooze out of the pie during baking, to avoid spoiling your oven’s surface, keep a tray or a flat plate below the pie bakeware. Keep an eye on your pie, checking  in between while letting it cook slowly.


Serve: Let the Pie sit for around 1-2 hours on the cooling rack, before you serve it…Believe me, it would be definitely worth the wait!


I took few shots while waiting for it to  cool down. These are few of the many.  Hope these encourage you to try one for yourself!



Eggless Apple Pie

Well, I hope you loved the “Pie – oh -my!”  It might be a little  long drawn and time-consuming process but it uses simple ingredients and is worth every effort you put in! Well if you don’t  trust me on this, let me give another try as I close this post and convince you by quoting a small except from a poem written by a famous American writer :

“But I, when I undress me
Each night, upon my knees
Will ask the Lord to bless me
With apple-pie and cheese!”

                                                                – Eugene Field

Let us know if have any questions relating to this recipe, &  if you do try it, please share the pics with us at



Categories: Mains | Tags: , , , , | 19 Comments

Post navigation

19 thoughts on “The Quintessential Apple Pie

  1. u kept us waiting for this recipe for too long but thank you, i got it at right moment .i will try it in next kitty.I hope it will b delicious.

    • Sorry Mummy, there were so many pictures..selecting and editing them was taking time! You are a pro.. I am sure coming from you it would come out really well! 🙂 Anyway. All the Best!

      • kanika

        U disappointed me too it came out absolutely rubbish! Never ever ever ever ever ever trusting hunger lane 156 ever again

      • Hi Kanika, We are sad to hear that this recipe did not work for you. Please tell us what did not work well – The Crust or the Filling. We do understand that to get the flaky crust is rather tricky but this recipe seemed to have worked for us. Having said that, we really hope that one bad experience does not deter you from trying out other recipes that we post.

  2. anonymous

    Came out DISGUSTING NASTY YUCK never tasted a load of mush before and the fact that I am a qualified professional baker this is NOT A GREAT WAY to make apple pie at ALL Do not try it. U kinda disappointed me a lot it is suchh a bad recipe. you should have SHAME for this recipe

    • Hey Anonymous, Thanks for sharing your feedback. We try to simplify the recipes for our readers so they are able to make it from simple ingredients from their kitchen. Having said, we also try these recipes for ourselves and with our friends before we post anything here. Kindly be more specific on what went wrong when you tried it. Sine you are a professional and we are home cooks.. we would certainly like to know from you how we could make this better.

      • maya

        It is the crust the filling is absolutely delish but the crust needs to be crusty no soggy!

      • Thanks for your valuable feedback Maya, our crust came out really flaky and crunchy with exact same proportions… and that is why we shared it with our readers.
        A lot of recipes we came across did not add baking powder but it seemed to have worked for us. We appreciate your addition and shall try it the next time we sit down to make Apple Pie! Thanks again.. keep writing!

      • anonymous

        Well if u add complete cold butter and try not to work the dough too much don’t worry hun. Mistakes haappen 😉

      • anonymous

        Increase the amount of cornstarch or add a little bit of custard powder it will fix ur prob

  3. Can I substitute corn starch with corn syrup?

    • Hi Vama,

      Thanks for sharing your query. To answer it, we cannot replace corn starch with Corn Syrup because corn starch is a thickening agent while corn syrup is a sweetener. Corn Starch has been used in this recipe to thicken the juices that ooze out of apples during the marinating process. Instead of corn starch you can use plain flour as substitute. Hope this addresses your doubt. Let us know how did it come out. We would love to hear your experience.


  4. Rashi's Fan

    Dont listen to them I am a professional and I know that if you double the recipe you get a thicker flaky pie crust

  5. Rashi's Fan

    I mean double the crust and tada!

    • Thanks for your approval Anonymous! We are glad to know! So, What is your profession exactly?.. we might seek your expertise! 🙂

      • Rashi's Fan

        I am a professional baker and pie maker.I love to bake anx would be more than happy to help u!
        you would require futher additional help email me!

Share your thoughts with us!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: